Current Projects
Making sense of the CPEC Controversy — III
by Rafiullah Kakar In my previous articles on the China-Pakistan Economic Corridor, I deconstructed the government’s claims about having prioritised the western route of the project as well as critically examined the various justifications advanced by those defending the prioritisation of the eastern route. In the concluding part of this series of articles, I aim to examine the way our public policy is developed and the trade-off that often occurs between concerns for equity and those for efficiency. Specifically, I will deconstruct the public policy paradigm underlying the arguments advanced in favour of the eastern route. Public policies aimed at regional development have traditionally tended to focus on the trade-off between equity and efficiency. Most of the arguments advanced to justify the prioritisation of the eastern route of the CPEC are based on the technocratic efficiency-based criterion. There are three major flaws in this line of reasoning. First, the efficiency-based criterion ignores the history of past injustices and the absence of a level playing field between the developed and the lagging regions of the country. Pakistan inherited regional inequality from the colonial period. The British had strategic interests in contemporary Balochistan, Fata and Khyber-Pakhtunkhwa (K-P) and therefore developed only the infrastructure that was vital for defence logistics. In contrast, they had deep economic and political interests in Punjab and Sindh. The infrastructure developed in these regions favoured agricultural growth and industrialisation. After Pakistan’s creation, the post-colonial ruling elite did very little to undo economic and political inequality among the different ethnic groups and regions. Power asymmetries among ethno-regional groups reinforced regional disparities and ensured that resource distribution remained biased in favour of Punjab. The fact that Pakhtun representation in the military and the bureaucracy significantly increased and...
Sabawoon Showcase: Regional review on Khyber Pakhtunkhwa (KP) and the Federally Administered Tribal Areas (FATA)
February 9, 2016, Peshawar: The Center for Research and Security Studies’ (CRSS) flagship radio program Sabawoon’s latest episode reviewed the security situation of the educational institutions in KP. The second part of the program focused on psychological stresses on the students, after terrorist attacks on Army Public School (APS) Peshawar and Bacha Khan University (BKU) Charsadda, lack of women and minorities’ participation in electoral system, and the development schemes in FATA’s Khyber Agency. The program, under the theme ‘Da Simi Jaaj’ (regional view), was aired on Tuesday. Mr. Muhammad Fahad Khan, District Nazim Charsadda, took part as a guest via telephone. Four reports were made part of the program from the districts of Charsadda, Peshawar, Swat and Khyber Agency. The first report shared the details about the security situation in the Government Girls High School (GGHS) Aziz Khail, Charsadda, and its impact on the students. Ms. Johar Taaj, Principal, GGHS said, “The boundary wall of the school has collapsed, due to which we are always in fear. I have requested relevant authorities, but I have not received any response yet. Students have a constant fear of a terrorist attack, due to which many students don’t come to attend the classes.” A student of this school, Ms. Zuhra, said, “If the government is not able to allocate funds for us, they should let us know, so that we will start a fundraising campaign to solve this issue.” Mr. Ikram Khan, a father of four daughters, who are all studying in GGHS, said, “I cannot send my daughters to their school because of the security reason. When they are in school, I am constantly praying for their safe return.’’ The second report emphasized the impacts of terrorist attacks on APS Peshawar and BKU Charsadda. These attacks are the reason of psychological stress in the students, which does not allow them to attend their school, colleges, and universities. Ms. Munawar, a school teacher, said, “We have become...
CRSS China Watch – February 12, 2016
In a meeting of the National Assembly Standing Committee on Commerce, it was stressed by the commerce minister that Pakistan seeks to sign the quadrilateral accord with China, Kyrgyzstan and Kazakhstan to reach Central Asia.[1] He said that bilateral trade relations with Afghanistan were not developing in a progressive way. Afghan government’s reaction towards the drafts of Preferential Trade Agreement (PTA) and Transit Trade Agreement (TTA) was disappointing. However, the government of Pakistan is bound to revive its trade relations under that quadrilateral accord without depending on Afghanistan, who intends to include India in the agreement, an unacceptable term for Pakistan. The government has also reserved Rs. 6 billion for smooth implementation of trade policy measures.[2] In Qatar, Prime Minister Nawaz Sharif referred to the growing economy of Pakistan while addressing a gathering of Pakistani expats. He said that various projects under the China Pakistan Economic Corridor (CPEC) will bring regional prosperity.[3] ____________________________________________________________________________ [1] http://tribune.com.pk/story/1045184/govt-seeks-to-revive-trade-deal-with-china-central-asia/ [2] http://www.brecorder.com/market-data/stocks-a-bonds/0/15383/ [3] http://en.dailypakistan.com.pk/headline/cpec-project-will-bring-prosperity-in-entire-region-pm/
Sabawoon Showcase: Negative Impact of Pashtu CD Dramas and Films on viewers.
February 8, 2016, Peshawar: The Center for Research and Security Studies’ (CRSS) flagship radio program Sabawoon’s latest episode focused on the negative influence of Pashtu CD dramas and films on the viewers. Moreover, the program discussed domestic violence and the degrading of women. The reformation of the screening council and censorship board was also highlighted. The program was aired under the theme “Jarga Marraka” (debate and council). Mr. Jamal Nasir, a director and filmmaker of Pashtu dramas, and Mr. Ghulam Mehmood Shahab, a senior broadcaster and actor, were the guests. A report on the program’s central shared the views of the public, artists, filmmakers and students. Mr. Nimat Khan, a local elder, said, “Pashtu CD dramas and films are one of the main reasons that spread violence, terror, and promote the use of drugs.” Mr. Iftikhar Khan, a drama writer, said, “These films and dramas are produced for business only, and have nothing to do with the Pashtun culture. In the long run, it can prove to be dangerous for our youngsters, as it has a direct impact on them due to the easy availability. Another local elder, Mr. Shakir Ullah, said, “These dramas and films have nothing to do with literature and recreation, and rather these frustrate the viewers. Whatever is depicted in these dramas and films is entirely opposite to Pashtun culture.” A total of six callers participated in the show. They demanded that the government ban these films and dramas and that a screening council for content and quality check should be reinstated. A caller on the show, Mr. Aziz Rehman Marwat, said, “There is a dire need for the government to establish a screening department to monitor the quality of audio and video production, because the producer’s concern is business related.” Another caller, Mr. Dill Jan Khan, said, “Some of the dramas and films are promoting the use of guns, which spread violence among youth. The youth is the target audience of these productions.” A third...
Beyond Boundaries
Positive Messaging Essential to Help Complex Afghan Peace Process: Foreign Secretary Pakistan’s foreign secretary Aizaz Ahmed Chaudhry says the speed with which the Quadrilateral Coordination Group (QCG) has moved reflects the commitment of all stakeholders to the Afghan peace and reconciliation. In a meeting with the Afghan members of the civil society, currently visiting Pakistan as part of the Beyond Boundaries – Pak-Afghan Track II/1.5 initiative undertaken by an Islamabad based Center for Research and Security Studies (CRSS), the chief diplomat said that Pakistan believes in a sovereign, united, prosperous, peaceful Afghanistan. This is in the interest of the entire region and that is why Pakistan together with the US and China is doing its best to help Afghans achieve the goal of peace and stability. “Hope and faith in the process as well as in Pakistan’s sincerity in the peace efforts will work better than continuous blame-game and skepticism”, Mr. Chaudhry added while underlining that you could inspire confidence only by staying positive. "Pakistan has developed a complete national consensus to counter-terrorism. The state of Pakistan is determined to deal with all those militants across the board who are killing innocent women and children both in Pakistan and Afghanistan". With regard to peace process in Afghanistan, the foreign secretary said "We must, sequence the process and take a step-by-step approach rather than coming up with pre-conditions by either side in an extremely complex and difficult process”. Pointing to the aggravated security situation, factional divisions and emergence of Daesh, Mr. Chaudhry said these factors posed big challenge to the QCG process but hoped that given the resolve of all four countries, they were not insurmountable. The foreign secretary also gave the Afghan delegation a run-down of the QCG meetings held so far and hoped its concerted efforts would result in direct intra-Afghan talks sooner than later. In that...
CRSS China Watch – February 10, 2016
The Austrian ambassador to Pakistan Dr. Brigitta Blahau underlined that the Austrian delegates in Pakistan have been exploring investment opportunities, specifically linked to the China-Pakistan Economic Corridor (CPEC), as it hold great significance in the foreign policy of Austria. In an interactive session at Pakistan Institute of International Affairs (PIIA), she conveyed the Austrian inclination to invest more in Pakistan.[1] Prime Minister Nawaz Sharif has diverted Rs. 20 billion, saved for other projects, to the road projects under the CPEC for the current financial year 2015-16. The Senate Standing Committee on Communication held a meeting with the Secretary Communication and Chairman National Highway Authority (NHA) Shahid Ashraf. It was notified by the committee that the government does not release funds in time even after its allocation. The committee also reported about the corruption in National Highways and Motorway Police (NH&MP) and urged the Prime Minister to look into this matter.[2] [1] http://www.dailytimes.com.pk/sindh/10-Feb-2016/cpec-attracts-austrian-investment-in-pakistan [2] http://www.brecorder.com/market-data/stocks-a-bonds/0/14394/
Reconciliation: Moving Forward?
by Imtiaz Gul Does the meeting between the heads of the Inter-Services Intelligence (ISI) and Afghanistan’s National Directorate of Security (NDS) on February 4 mark the turning of a new page in bilateral relations? Ostensibly, yes. And for a number of reasons. First, following the revelation of Mullah Omar’s death last year, the hostility towards Pakistan in Afghanistan had peaked to unprecedented levels. As a consequence, most of the leadership in Kabul had refused to travel to Islamabad. Most Afghan political parties and the media were up in arms, questioning their government and Pakistan’s motives for proposing intelligence cooperation. The NDS Director-General Masud Andrabi’s presence in Islamabad means the Afghan security establishment has ended the self-imposed ban on coming over. This is indeed a big step forward, given the acrimonious context prevailing since July last year. Second, on January 30, Corps Commander Lieutenant General Mohammad Sharif Yaftali led an eight-member delegation of the Afghan National Army to Peshawar Corps Headquarters, where rare consultations were held with Corps Commander Lieutenant General Hidayatur Rehman on enhancing coordination and security measures on both sides of the border, a demand Pakistan has often flagged with Afghanistan as part of its counter-terrorism campaign. Third, this rare face-to-face NDS-ISI interaction came ahead of the Quadrilateral Contact Group’s (QCG) February 6 round, sparking hopes that both sides were possibly inching towards closer cooperation — an unavoidable prerequisite for making some sense out of the QCG’s incremental approach on the reconciliation endeavour. Viewed against former NDS chief Rahmatullah Nabeel’s hawkish views on Pakistan (and his aversion to the word ‘border’ for the Durand Line) and the sheer displeasure that he had expressed in his resignation a day before the Heart of Asia Conference on December 9 in Islamabad, Andrabi’s discussions with General Rizwan Akhtar assumed...
Conducive Ambiance Must for Strengthening People To People Relationship and Impulses for Peace, Stability and Cooperation
The peace process should continue with added transparency and in line with globally accepted fundamental values. Increasing bilateral trade and expeditious completion of Pakistani infrastructural projects in Afghanistan can be conducive to improving Af-Pak economic relations. The role of free media can be of an enormous significance in improving mutual perceptions. The fundamental human rights of Afghan - with their refugee status in Pakistan - should not be ignored while also facilitating their voluntary repatriation to their homeland. The cultural ties between Afghanistan and Pakistan should be promoted by building on existing historical linkages. Opportunities for educational collaboration must be explored and considered by both the governments. Pakistan and Afghanistan - reviewing respective educational curricula - can promote universal values of tolerance, peace and civic education. Mobilizing private sector investments needs enabling environment. These were the notions presented by the members of Pakistani and Afghan civil society working groups during the regional civil society workshop held from February 8-9, 2016 at Bhurban. The workshop was a fifth major round in the series of meetings between civil society and regional security experts of both countries as part of “Beyond Boundaries”, a major Af-Pak track 1.5 and II initiative launched by an Islamabad based Center for Research and Security Studies (CRSS) - in partnership with its Afghan counterpart organization, DURAN Research and Analysis (DRA) and sub-national partner (Pakistan), the Foundation for Integrated Development Action (FIDA) as an effort to improve relations between Afghanistan and Pakistan, soothe bitter context, tackle trust deficit which can somehow de-escalate the heightened tensions and improve mutual perceptions. The Afghan and Pakistani working groups welcomed the Quadrilateral dialogue and the decision taken by respective states to hold another session on Feb 23rd 2016 in the hope...
After Years of Violence, Pakistan Is Winning Its Fight Against Terrorism
by Murtaza Hussain A group of men from the militant Islamist group Tehrik-e-Taliban Pakistan infiltrated the campus of Bacha Khan University in northwestern Pakistan. Armed with assault rifles and grenades, they managed to kill over 20 students and faculty before they were gunned down by local security forces. The attack managed to shock a country that for years has endured terrorist outrages. That the killings occurred at a university, targeting innocent students and teachers, made them feel particularly heinous. But the attack was also remarkable because Pakistan, for more than a year, had appeared to be on the way to finally defeating its homegrown insurgency. And despite the horror of what happened at Bacha Khan, that still seems to be the case. Last year saw precipitous decreases in both terrorist attacks and fatalities in Pakistan. Though exact figures differ, statistics compiled by the South Asia Terrorism Portal, the research arm of the New Delhi-based Institute for Conflict Management, as well as a study by the Islamabad-based Center for Research and Security Studies, a pro-democracy think tank, showed significant decreases in violence in the country. A CRSS study said terrorist incidents declined 56 percent in 2015 from 2014, and the SATP, which conducts a running tally of terrorism figures, said that Pakistan in 2015 suffered the lowest number of suicide attacks and deaths from terrorism since 2006. These reported declines follow Pakistan’s initiation in 2014 of a large-scale military operation against Taliban sanctuaries in the ungoverned tribal areas bordering Afghanistan. That effort, which is ongoing, has succeeded in reclaiming most territory in the tribal areas. The seven years preceding this operation coincided with the escalation of the American war in Afghanistan and were among the bloodiest in Pakistan’s history. Those years saw a deluge of terrorist attacks that targeted markets, shrines, mosques, and major landmarks throughout the country....
To Protect Chinese Investment, Pakistan Military Leaves Little to Chance
by Syed Raza Hassan A heavy police presence, guarded convoys, new checkpoints and troop reinforcements have turned parts of the southern port city of Gwadar into a fortress, as Pakistan's powerful military seeks to protect billions of dollars of Chinese investment. Securing the planned $46 billion economic corridor of roads, railways and pipelines from northwest China to Pakistan's Arabian Sea coast is a huge challenge in a country where Islamist militants and separatist gunmen are a constant menace. The armed forces and interior ministry have sent hundreds of extra soldiers and police to Gwadar, the southern hub of the so-called China-Pakistan Economic Corridor (CPEC), and more are on their way. "Soon we'll start hiring 700-800 police to be part of a separate security unit dedicated to Chinese security, and at a later stage a new security division would be formed," Jafer Khan, regional police officer in Gwadar told Reuters. A senior security official in the town of around 100,000 people said a further 400-500 soldiers had been recruited as a temporary measure to protect Chinese nationals. On a recent visit, an SUV carrying Chinese visitors was escorted by two police cars and an army vehicle, while police blocked traffic at every crossroad along the route. It was not clear who the passengers were. Keeping foreign workers and executives safe in Gwadar, which has expanded significantly over the last 15 years largely thanks to Chinese investment, is relatively straightforward. The same cannot be said of the corridor as a whole. Its western branch passes north through Baluchistan province, where ethnic Baluch separatist rebels are opposed to the CPEC project and chafing under a military crackdown. It skirts the tribal belt along the Afghan-Pakistan border where Islamist militant groups including the Pakistan Taliban and al Qaeda have long been based, and takes in Peshawar, scene of some of the worst insurgent atrocities of recent years. CRACKDOWN AND ANGER The main...
TOP STORIES
TESTIMONIALS
“
I am also a member of National Assembly’s Standing Committee on Information and Broadcasting. Recently, we held a meeting with the Director General of Radio Pakistan and we told them to initiate such local programs (like Constituency Hour) in regional languages to educate and inform people. Even Indian Radio can be heard in FATA which is being used for propaganda purposes and must be closed. Therefore, we should launch some standard and quality programs like CRSS that will change the taste of the listeners.