Current Projects
Double dilemma: US drones and Afghan denouncements
Thiscomment originally appeared in the Express Tribune on July 4,2013. The July 2 drone strike on a target 50 kms off Miranshah -14th this year ´ evoked another strong protest from the ministry of foreign affairs. This 'outrage' came less than four weeks after the Foreign Office summoned US Charge d– Affaires (CdA), Deputy Ambassador Richard Hoagland, on June 8 to lodge a similar 'strong protest' against a strike that had killed seven people in a North Waziristan village. Do these expressions of rejection and demands for cessation in strikes count? Apparently little because of the US-UK understanding that drones represent an important tool in hunting down terrorists. This issue merits scrutiny in the context of two major geo-political factors to explain as to why these strikes, though on the wane, are likely to continue i) The broad US-NATO agreement on the use of drones against common 'enemies', ii) Increasingly wobbly leadership of a volatile Afghanistan Speaking in Los Angeles on June 25, UK Foreign Secretary William Hague said about the UK policy on intelligence-sharing with the United States: 'We operate under the rule of law and are accountable for it. In some countries secret intelligence is used to control their people. In ours, it only exists to protect their freedoms.' Allegations that Government Communications Headquarters (GCHQ) used a US programme to circumvent the law and spy on British citizens have led to renewed calls for the agency to disclose what its policy is on providing intelligence to support CIA drone strikes. Anti-drone campaigners claim that by sharing intelligence in support of the campaign, GCHQ may have broken both domestic and international law. As for Afghanistan, the pressures from across the border are mounting; the Afghan army chief General Sher Mohammad Karimi who, in a BBC interview broadcast July 3, claimed that Pakistan was complicit in drone attacks because Islamabad had 'given the lists' of militants it wants taken out. He...
Dialogue Forum: Caught between Optimism and Skepticism: Challenges for Government
Quetta Press Club, June 28, 2013 CRSS team held a Discussion Forum with leading journalists and civil society representatives On June 28, 2013 at the Quetta Press Club. The focus of this DF was the post-elections situation in the province and the challenges facing the new government led by Dr. Abdul Malik Baloch. Most participants were extremely cautious about the ability of the new government to cope with the pressing insecurity issues which they listed as the biggest challenge to the government. Abdul Khaliq, senior reporter for the largest circulation Urdu daily 'Jang' said simmering issue such as the killing of Baloch nationalists, target-killings of shia Hazaras and non-Baloch settlers, attacks on journalists, and missing persons constituted the core of the security crisis. Shehzada Zulfiqar, correspondent for daily Pakistan Today and a human rights– activist said the role of security agencies, Baloch politicians, and the federal government were critical for improvement in the situation. Unless they are all on the same page, situation is not likely to improve. Rectifying acute deficiencies in governance i.e. absence of merit and rule of law represents another major challenge for the government. 'If political appointments from a clerk to a senior officer to a school or university teacher remain subject to political influence, nothing will change,' Israr Baloch, a student activist from Naseerabad observed. He said past governments mostly comprised turncoats who had neither any political commitment nor any vision for the socio-economic progress of the people. Education therefore is in a shambles following a massive brain-drain of non-Baloch teachers in the last couple of years because of a relentless campaign of target-killings. Political influence essentially compromises the ability of the institutions to perform on merit and independently. Most participants listed corruption as the third biggest challenge. Almost every speaker questioned as to where did all...
Strategic blunder
Thiscomment originally appeared in the Friday Times on June 28,2013 Pakistan denied its purported contacts with and influence over key Taliban leaders for years. Civil and military officials would reject out of hand any link whatsoever with any Taliban leaders. They also expressed ignorance of the whereabouts of the militant leadership. Beginning early this year, they forgot all those denials and turned over 26 Taliban prisoners in two installments, saying the rest - about a dozen or so - would be set free as and when necessary. By doing so, the Pakistani leadership essentially began admitting what they had been brushing aside as allegations and propaganda. But the bait by American interlocutors (Pakistan is being made relevant to the Afghan reconciliation process) worked, and one after the other, Islamabad and Rawalpindi pulled out cards - first the Taliban prisoners, then linking up the most hunted and condemned terrorists Haqqanis with the Americans, and now claiming credit for what turned out to be, at least for the time being, a big faux pax at Doha ie the Taliban office and the ensuing controversy over the flag of "Islamic Emirate of Afghanistan". Then, by taking credit for the Taliban office formally launched on June 18 amid great fanfare, Pakistan again displayed the usual indecent haste. Only a day later, Afghan President Hamid Karzai stunned his western backers by announcing a suspension of talks on the Bilateral Security Agreement (BSA) with the United States. Ironically, Pakistani officials went the Karzai way, and during special envoy James Dobbins' Islamabad visit, they expressed fears that the initiative might break down due to the 'contradictory approach' of Afghan President Hamid Karzai's administration. Before that, for two days, newspapers in Pakistan were awash with official chest-thumping for "Pakistan's instrumental role in the reconciliation." Even Foreign Ministry officials went public with a credit-taking, self-adulatory statement,...
“Students must work for Equal Citizenry “
CRSS team visited Government General Musa College in Murree Abad on June 28, 2013. This college is named after General Musa Khan, a former governor, who belonged to the minority shia Hazara community. The minority Hazara community has been under attack particularly since 2011 in particular and CRSS decided to hold a lecture there as a mark of solidarity with the Hazaras. While most people from within Balochistan as well as from outside are reluctant in visiting Hazara areas for fear of attacks by terrorists, CRSS decided to interact with the students of the College. Welcoming the CRSS for this bold initiative, the principal Mr.Mukhtiar Jaffry thanked the organization for visiting the college in adverse conditions. He also hoped such activity will be repeated in future as well to give hope and moral support to the Hazara people. In his lecture CRSS CEO, Imtiaz Gul, spoke about the need for not giving up hope and patience. He said despite adverse circumstances, the youth must stay positive because they are the real future leaders who can turn adversity into opportunities. Youth are a pack of energy and ideas. They must step forward to realize the ideals of a democratic society based on a constitution that promises equal rights to every citizen. Gul urged the students to vigorously multiply the message that 'every single person living on the Pakistani territory is entitled to, and must be accorded, equal fundamental rights.' Disregard the claims of responsibility of acts of terror by one or the other group. These are primarily part of a concerted campaign to terrorize people at large and sow fear in their hearts and minds. This terror campaign has various manifestations from the north to southern and southwestern Pakistan i. ethnic, linguistic, nationalistic, religious or political. This must not deter the youth from working for peace, democracy, inclusive dialogue. Essentially the conversation must be embedded in constitutionalism, secular and dispassionate, Gul...
"Students must work for Equal Citizenry "
CRSS team visited Government General Musa College in Murree Abad on June 28, 2013. This college is named after General Musa Khan, a former governor, who belonged to the minority shia Hazara community. The minority Hazara community has been under attack particularly since 2011 in particular and CRSS decided to hold a lecture there as a mark of solidarity with the Hazaras. While most people from within Balochistan as well as from outside are reluctant in visiting Hazara areas for fear of attacks by terrorists, CRSS decided to interact with the students of the College. Welcoming the CRSS for this bold initiative, the principal Mr.Mukhtiar Jaffry thanked the organization for visiting the college in adverse conditions. He also hoped such activity will be repeated in future as well to give hope and moral support to the Hazara people. In his lecture CRSS CEO, Imtiaz Gul, spoke about the need for not giving up hope and patience. He said despite adverse circumstances, the youth must stay positive because they are the real future leaders who can turn adversity into opportunities. Youth are a pack of energy and ideas. They must step forward to realize the ideals of a democratic society based on a constitution that promises equal rights to every citizen. Gul urged the students to vigorously multiply the message that 'every single person living on the Pakistani territory is entitled to, and must be accorded, equal fundamental rights.' Disregard the claims of responsibility of acts of terror by one or the other group. These are primarily part of a concerted campaign to terrorize people at large and sow fear in their hearts and minds. This terror campaign has various manifestations from the north to southern and southwestern Pakistan i. ethnic, linguistic, nationalistic, religious or political. This must not deter the youth from working for peace, democracy, inclusive dialogue. Essentially the conversation must be embedded in constitutionalism, secular and dispassionate, Gul...
"Students must work for Equal Citizenry "
CRSS team visited Government General Musa College in Murree Abad on June 28, 2013. This college is named after General Musa Khan, a former governor, who belonged to the minority shia Hazara community. The minority Hazara community has been under attack particularly since 2011 in particular and CRSS decided to hold a lecture there as a mark of solidarity with the Hazaras. While most people from within Balochistan as well as from outside are reluctant in visiting Hazara areas for fear of attacks by terrorists, CRSS decided to interact with the students of the College. Welcoming the CRSS for this bold initiative, the principal Mr.Mukhtiar Jaffry thanked the organization for visiting the college in adverse conditions. He also hoped such activity will be repeated in future as well to give hope and moral support to the Hazara people. In his lecture CRSS CEO, Imtiaz Gul, spoke about the need for not giving up hope and patience. He said despite adverse circumstances, the youth must stay positive because they are the real future leaders who can turn adversity into opportunities. Youth are a pack of energy and ideas. They must step forward to realize the ideals of a democratic society based on a constitution that promises equal rights to every citizen. Gul urged the students to vigorously multiply the message that 'every single person living on the Pakistani territory is entitled to, and must be accorded, equal fundamental rights.' Disregard the claims of responsibility of acts of terror by one or the other group. These are primarily part of a concerted campaign to terrorize people at large and sow fear in their hearts and minds. This terror campaign has various manifestations from the north to southern and southwestern Pakistan i. ethnic, linguistic, nationalistic, religious or political. This must not deter the youth from working for peace, democracy, inclusive dialogue. Essentially the conversation must be embedded in constitutionalism, secular and dispassionate, Gul...
Youth can ensure accountability of MPs
Quetta ´ Youth of Balochistan hold the key to the social accountability of politicians and ensuring rule of law. The role of youth for community-driven monitoring of public sector organizations is equally crucial for better social service delivery and good governance. These were some of the thoughts that came under discussion in an interactive session of Balochistan University students and civil society representatives atthe Social Work Department on Thursday. The session was part of the series of Balochistan Youth Forum activities that the Centre for Research and Security Studies (CRSS) is currently holding in various parts of Balochistan with the support of CIDA.The objective of the BYF is to promote the spirit of democratic dialogue and allow the Baloch youth to ventilate their grievances. The second phaseof the BYF will take selected Baloch youth to Islamabad and other cities of Pakistan for interaction with students of various universities and politicians. Speaking on the occasion, Imtiaz Gul, political analyst and CRSS chief executive, said that 'future leaders' were the key to socio-economic development and the badly needed democratic transition. 'Elections and governments resulting from this exercise are just a means for securing social, economic rights as well as political emancipation. You can get closer to the end goal of equal fundamental rights for all only through continuation of this exercise,' Gul explained, citing the example ofIreland, where the Irish Republican Party had to create a political wing for negotiations with the UK government. Political groups can, however, become the instruments of change only if they act according to the constitutional framework anduphold the fundamentals of rule of law, Gul said. 'The ultimate check on political parties is the people themselves. Unless they collectively make their representatives and governance institutions accountable the dream for an equal-for-all and inclusive democracy would remain elusive,'...
Elitist Indifference to sacrifice
June 5, 2013 was a great day in Pakistan's democratic transition.Forthe first time in the country's existence since 1947,Pakistanis witnessed an elected government replace another one as a result of the general elections held onMay 11. There was another historical record attached to this day: the newly elected representatives had just gonethrough the bloodiest election campaign in the history of Pakistan. Nearly 26 National Assembly constituencies and 35 provincial Assembly constituencies were witness to target killings, injuries, destruction and kidnappings that were mostly carried out by militant organisations resulting in the death of 244 persons, including seven candidates for the National and provincial Assemblies: Fakhrul Islam (MQM) NA-221, PS-47, Malik Adnan Khan Wazir (ANP) PK-72, Sadiq Zaman Khattak (ANP) NA-254, Adnan Qualeti (PPP) PS-95, Muhammad Zahir Shah Khan (PPP) PK-96, Abdul Fateh Magsi (independent) PB-32, and Shakeel Ahmed (MQM-H) NA-241 and PS-95. If some of the targeted candidates were lucky enough to escape the deadly attacks, their loved ones, like sons, brothers, and cousins were not. Most of these unfortunate people were sent to their graves by some unknown and unidentifiable creatures using guns, bombs, hand grenades and suicide bombers. Those who claimed responsibility remained beyond the reach of the law-enforcing authorities and were ignored by the people and their leaders too. The number of injured persons was three times higher than the dead ones and all those parliamentarians that now occupy the new National and provincial Assembly seats owe their success to the sacrifices of these people. The security threats that loomed large in the country during the election campaign were very lucidly described by the army chief General Ashfaq Kayani in these words: 'The nation withstood the threat of terrorism and defied the unfounded dictates of an insignificant and misguided minority by actively participating in the general elections.' Alas,...
Monthly Data Sheet – May 2013
Pakistan Conflict Tracker Monthly Report – May 2013
The month of May was historical and very crucial for the people of Pakistan for two reasons; they were going to elect a new government to run the country for the next five years and that they had to show that they believed more in peaceful methods for transfer of power rather than taking the violent route. Despite an exhibition of common consensus of the people for peaceful transfer of power, the political campaign remained highly violent and the month of May recorded casualties of 1301 persons (Killed ´ 499 and Injured ´ 702). The data collected throughten newspapers that CRSS uses as the source, suggests that nearly 499 people lost their lives in 274 incidents of violence across the country (for details see Table 1). The violent clashes also left 702 people injured in May. Table 1: Monthly data of casualties of violence Like previous months, three provinces, Sindh, Balochistan, and KPK/FATA had the highest number of casualties during the month of May as well (Graph 1). Graph 1: Deaths due to violence in Pakistan As usual, civilians were the highest victims of violence during the month of May and militants and security officials had the next highest casualties. Among the civilians, the highest number of victims was of the political candidates, activists, and supporters. The victims of violence belonging to different political parties accounted for half of the total casualties (173 killed and 441 injured) and the victims were from all political parties that were taking part in the election (Graph 2). Graph 2: Violence Victims and their affiliation Of the 499 casualties of political violence, Taliban claimed the responsibility for 137 casualties that took place in Karachi [1] and Orakzai, Kurrum Agency[2]. Major causes of casualties: As in case of previous months, target killing and missile/shelling were the major causes of deaths in May as well. Pie chart II below shows that 35 percent of all the violent incidents were of target killing in nature. Karachi suffered...
TOP STORIES
TESTIMONIALS
“
I am also a member of National Assembly’s Standing Committee on Information and Broadcasting. Recently, we held a meeting with the Director General of Radio Pakistan and we told them to initiate such local programs (like Constituency Hour) in regional languages to educate and inform people. Even Indian Radio can be heard in FATA which is being used for propaganda purposes and must be closed. Therefore, we should launch some standard and quality programs like CRSS that will change the taste of the listeners.