Current Projects

The Terrorism Debate: Flogging the Wrong Horse

Pakistan’s current debate on terrorism apparently suffers from an acute lack of understanding of the real issues that lie at the heart of its security crisis. Much of the discourse on the possible drivers of terrorism and radicalisation centres mostly on religious seminaries, partly for the wrong reasons. And this means a superficial diagnosis of the problem. This also suggests that the recipe prescribed can be equally skewed. The majority of liberals hold madrassas responsible for both terrorism and the radicalisation of minds. The government, led by Interior Minister Chaudhry Nisar thinks the same. Politicians, in general, blame terrorism on the policies that the military establishment pursued in the past. They are equally contemptuous of the judiciary, which they say has been rather conformist. The military, on its part, often claims that the civilian government and the judiciary carry the burden of responsibility for not being strong enough against alleged terrorists. Police experts say the conviction rate of terror suspects is disappointing because of lack of coordination between the police and the prosecution. “Completion of challans is delayed in cases in which the accused are unidentified, like wall-chalkings, and prosecution suffers because fresh law graduates inducted in the police department lack experience.” Participants at a recent top-level meeting held in Islamabad to review the implementation of the National Action Plan (NAP) and the conviction of accused were surprised to learn that 90 per cent of cases are pending in the courts. This is in sharp contrast to what the NAP had promised regarding speedy trials, with day-to-day hearings taking place. Even cases registered under the Anti-Terrorism Act (ATA) are not being heard daily. The bench i.e., the judiciary apportions the blame on the bar and the executive. The superior judiciary, on the other hand, faults the lower courts and lawyers for the low conviction rate and execution of punishments. For...

‘Find, Fix, Finish’

Few innovations in modern warfare have seduced US presidents as thoroughly as the Predator drone, upstaged in more recent years by its bigger and even deadlier cousin, the Reaper. Under George W Bush, the Hellfire missiles slung under its wings delivered 'sudden justice' to America's enemies. Barack Obama embraced the technology even more ardently, carrying out eight times more drone strikes in Pakistan than his predecessor and opening new fronts in Yemen and Somalia. It is not hard to imagine why temptation proved so hard to resist. With their sleek fuselages and distinctive downward-V tail fins, drones serve as 'aerial sniper rifles', allowing the pinpoint application of deadly force without putting American troops in danger. Unlike conventional aircraft, drones can 'slow down war' by loitering above a target for hours, ensuring civilian casualties are kept to a minimum. The unblinking stare from their swivelling, robotic eyes ensures the most dangerous militants remain forever on the run. To their promoters, these bulbous-nosed craft are an exemplar of how technological superiority can keep America safe. Chris Woods, an investigative journalist, takes a wrecking ball to this narrative with his authoritative and admirably even-handed chronicle of America's secret drone wars. Woods argues that drone strikes have led to five hundred unacknowledged non-combatant deaths, despite 'fanciful' CIA claims to the contrary. No longer reserved for 'high-value targets', drones have been used to obliterate hazily defined groups of 'military-aged males' mourning at funerals or desperately digging people from the rubble left by previous strikes. Operating far beyond public scrutiny, the CIA has used its covert fleet to wage an open-ended campaign of targeted killings that would have been unthinkable prior to 9/11, when American spy chiefs were wary of embracing assassination on an industrial scale. None of these controversies are new. The strength of Woods's book lies in the...

'Find, Fix, Finish'

Few innovations in modern warfare have seduced US presidents as thoroughly as the Predator drone, upstaged in more recent years by its bigger and even deadlier cousin, the Reaper. Under George W Bush, the Hellfire missiles slung under its wings delivered 'sudden justice' to America's enemies. Barack Obama embraced the technology even more ardently, carrying out eight times more drone strikes in Pakistan than his predecessor and opening new fronts in Yemen and Somalia. It is not hard to imagine why temptation proved so hard to resist. With their sleek fuselages and distinctive downward-V tail fins, drones serve as 'aerial sniper rifles', allowing the pinpoint application of deadly force without putting American troops in danger. Unlike conventional aircraft, drones can 'slow down war' by loitering above a target for hours, ensuring civilian casualties are kept to a minimum. The unblinking stare from their swivelling, robotic eyes ensures the most dangerous militants remain forever on the run. To their promoters, these bulbous-nosed craft are an exemplar of how technological superiority can keep America safe. Chris Woods, an investigative journalist, takes a wrecking ball to this narrative with his authoritative and admirably even-handed chronicle of America's secret drone wars. Woods argues that drone strikes have led to five hundred unacknowledged non-combatant deaths, despite 'fanciful' CIA claims to the contrary. No longer reserved for 'high-value targets', drones have been used to obliterate hazily defined groups of 'military-aged males' mourning at funerals or desperately digging people from the rubble left by previous strikes. Operating far beyond public scrutiny, the CIA has used its covert fleet to wage an open-ended campaign of targeted killings that would have been unthinkable prior to 9/11, when American spy chiefs were wary of embracing assassination on an industrial scale. None of these controversies are new. The strength of Woods's book lies in the...

Afghanistan: Light at the End of the Tunnel

A triple ‘S’ ambience accompanied the intra-Afghan peace talks at Murree: shock, surprise and scepticism. The talks first came as a shock to the detractors of Afghan President Ashraf Ghani’s policy on Pakistan, the group of people in Kabul who had thought that they had kicked up enough dust over the NDS-ISI deal to put Ghani on the defensive. Many others never expected players like Hikmet Karzai, the official chief negotiator — considered a Karzai associate — to be part of the talks and thus were painfully surprised to see the Afghan Taliban and government officials hugging each other at the end of a marathon meeting. And of course, several quarters greeted the process with deep scepticism and continue to be sceptical about the durability of the delicate interaction. Doubts also surround the process because of the hitherto unexplained absence of the mercurial Taliban chief Mullah Omar. His whereabouts are unknown and that has sowed divisions between the Taliban field commanders and their political leadership ensconced either in Doha or Islamabad. Viewed against this backdrop i.e., the simmering violence in parts of Afghanistan, fierce opposition to the Ghani-led peace process and widespread scepticism over the purposefulness of the talks, there is little doubt that this latest round of talks with the Afghan Taliban has unleashed a new, much more promising dynamic within the region. Firstly, an embattled Ghani, assured by external stakeholders such as the US and China, has emerged as the great lone crusader in a minefield of odds. Singlehandedly, the physically frail president has fought off many enemies, including the majority of parliamentarians in the Woolasi Jirga, as well as most of his own security apparatus led by a hostile National Directorate of Security (NDS). He also fended off, and continues to do so, the Karzai legacy, which represents: a) Pakhtun nationalists; b) those Afghans critical of Pakistan; c) forces of the status quo which have thrived on...

One more PLA Senior Officer busted, total now at 38

PLA disciplinary inspectors on Friday said they are investigating Deng Ruihua, former political commissar of the joint logistics department of Lanzhou Militate Area Command,for alleged "serious violations of discipline and laws." Earlier in April, the PLA disciplinary inspected annouced they were investigating another PLA high ranking officer Zhan Guoqiao who were Commander of the same department of Lanzhou Military Area Command. So far, China's anticorruption campaign already brought down a totalof 38 high ranking officers. The article is written by Rong Liu on People's Daily Online    

‘Extorted’ Donations: Karachi’s multi-million dollar Charity Business

BACKGROUND- During the Islamic holy month of fasting – “Ramzan”- there are two Islmaic obligations which according to “sharia” are compulsory on all Muslims; “Zakat” and “Fitra”. Zakat is a form of obligatory alms-giving and religious tax in Islam. It is based on income and the value of all of one's possessions. Zakat is one of the five pillars of Islam and mandatory for all Muslims, it is a charitable contribution. Fitra is a again a compulsory charity with a minimum amount of Rs100 per head, to be paid before Eidul Fitr (which marks the celebration after the month of Ramzan). Both Zakat and Fitra in the form of donations are collected all over Pakistan by religious as well as political parties’ charitable and philanthropist organizations. The collection of Zakat and Fitra has thus become a multi- million dollar business, but more so in Karachi, being the largest city population wise with an estimated population of about 20 million. Unfortunately this charitable side of religion has become a sort of ‘tug of war’ amongst the charity foundations of most religious and political parties, mainly the Muhajir Qaumi Movement (MQM), the Jamaat-e-Islami (JI), Pakistan Sunni Tehreek (PST), and others. It becomes victim to the unrelenting violence – when organizations start fighting to collect more donations and the competition ultimately leads to violence. This was the way things were done in Karachi. Until this year when mandated by the provincial Apex Committee (formed in sync with the National Actiion Plan), the Rangers decided to act. Through a press release last month the Rangers also claimed that these donation funds were being used to finance terrorism as well. The Sindh Rangers have come down hard on political parties and their welfare wings, accusing them of forcefully collecting donations. Workers are being arrested, cash and Fitra slips are being confiscated and a helpline has been set up where people can register complaints against forceful collection. The...

Pakistan’s Top Militant Commanders

Mullah Fazlullah A Yousufzai from Swat, he took charge as the head of the Tehreek-i-Taliban Pakistan after the death of Hakimullah Mehsud in a drone strike in November 2013. He is currently heading the TTP faction often referred to as “TTP central” in intelligence circles. He controlled large parts of the Malakand division for nearly three years before escaping to Afghanistan in 2009 following a military operation.  Fazlullah has been the mastermind behind various high profile attacks including the brutal Peshawar school attack as well as the killing of GoC Swat Major General Sanaullah Khan Niazi. He maintains good relations with the Afghan Taliban. Affiliated with: Tehreek-i-Taliban Pakistan (TTP) Maulana Asim Umar The head of Al-Qaeda in the Indian Subcontinent (AQIS) and the first Deobandi to lead an Al-Qaeda franchise. He has studied in Karachi and also taught at seminaries there. He has authored several books on subjects such as doomsday, the Anti-Christ, and Freemasons, etc. He is well-connected with various Deobandi and Salafi scholars and enjoys a good reputation in various religious circles. Affiliated with: Al-Qaeda in the Indian Subcontinent (AQIS) Sirajuddin Haqqani Commonly known as “Khalifa Sahib”, he heads what the US refers to as the Haqqani Network, which is in fact a group fighting under the direct command of Mullah Omar. His fighters are some of the best-trained militants in this region, and have carried out a number of high profile attacks in Afghanistan. Sirajuddin Haqqani’s step mother is a Yemeni, and he maintains close ties with Al Qaeda. When questioned about the TTP, he has referred to them as “our brothers”. He was a close friend of former TTP chief Hakimullah Mehsud. Affiliated with: Haqqani Network, TTP, Al-Qaeda Hafiz Saeed Khan Orakzai He had previously served as a TTP commander in Orakzai Agency. He parted ways with the TTP and joined Abu Bakr al-Baghdadi’s “Islamic State” (IS). In January this year, he was appointed as a...

Pakistan's Top Militant Commanders

Mullah Fazlullah A Yousufzai from Swat, he took charge as the head of the Tehreek-i-Taliban Pakistan after the death of Hakimullah Mehsud in a drone strike in November 2013. He is currently heading the TTP faction often referred to as “TTP central” in intelligence circles. He controlled large parts of the Malakand division for nearly three years before escaping to Afghanistan in 2009 following a military operation.  Fazlullah has been the mastermind behind various high profile attacks including the brutal Peshawar school attack as well as the killing of GoC Swat Major General Sanaullah Khan Niazi. He maintains good relations with the Afghan Taliban. Affiliated with: Tehreek-i-Taliban Pakistan (TTP) Maulana Asim Umar The head of Al-Qaeda in the Indian Subcontinent (AQIS) and the first Deobandi to lead an Al-Qaeda franchise. He has studied in Karachi and also taught at seminaries there. He has authored several books on subjects such as doomsday, the Anti-Christ, and Freemasons, etc. He is well-connected with various Deobandi and Salafi scholars and enjoys a good reputation in various religious circles. Affiliated with: Al-Qaeda in the Indian Subcontinent (AQIS) Sirajuddin Haqqani Commonly known as “Khalifa Sahib”, he heads what the US refers to as the Haqqani Network, which is in fact a group fighting under the direct command of Mullah Omar. His fighters are some of the best-trained militants in this region, and have carried out a number of high profile attacks in Afghanistan. Sirajuddin Haqqani’s step mother is a Yemeni, and he maintains close ties with Al Qaeda. When questioned about the TTP, he has referred to them as “our brothers”. He was a close friend of former TTP chief Hakimullah Mehsud. Affiliated with: Haqqani Network, TTP, Al-Qaeda Hafiz Saeed Khan Orakzai He had previously served as a TTP commander in Orakzai Agency. He parted ways with the TTP and joined Abu Bakr al-Baghdadi’s “Islamic State” (IS). In January this year, he was appointed as a...

Pakistan's Top Militant Commanders

Mullah Fazlullah A Yousufzai from Swat, he took charge as the head of the Tehreek-i-Taliban Pakistan after the death of Hakimullah Mehsud in a drone strike in November 2013. He is currently heading the TTP faction often referred to as “TTP central” in intelligence circles. He controlled large parts of the Malakand division for nearly three years before escaping to Afghanistan in 2009 following a military operation.  Fazlullah has been the mastermind behind various high profile attacks including the brutal Peshawar school attack as well as the killing of GoC Swat Major General Sanaullah Khan Niazi. He maintains good relations with the Afghan Taliban. Affiliated with: Tehreek-i-Taliban Pakistan (TTP) Maulana Asim Umar The head of Al-Qaeda in the Indian Subcontinent (AQIS) and the first Deobandi to lead an Al-Qaeda franchise. He has studied in Karachi and also taught at seminaries there. He has authored several books on subjects such as doomsday, the Anti-Christ, and Freemasons, etc. He is well-connected with various Deobandi and Salafi scholars and enjoys a good reputation in various religious circles. Affiliated with: Al-Qaeda in the Indian Subcontinent (AQIS) Sirajuddin Haqqani Commonly known as “Khalifa Sahib”, he heads what the US refers to as the Haqqani Network, which is in fact a group fighting under the direct command of Mullah Omar. His fighters are some of the best-trained militants in this region, and have carried out a number of high profile attacks in Afghanistan. Sirajuddin Haqqani’s step mother is a Yemeni, and he maintains close ties with Al Qaeda. When questioned about the TTP, he has referred to them as “our brothers”. He was a close friend of former TTP chief Hakimullah Mehsud. Affiliated with: Haqqani Network, TTP, Al-Qaeda Hafiz Saeed Khan Orakzai He had previously served as a TTP commander in Orakzai Agency. He parted ways with the TTP and joined Abu Bakr al-Baghdadi’s “Islamic State” (IS). In January this year, he was appointed as a...

Pakistan’s Minorities: A Case of Systematic Marginalization

“India grants citizenship to 4300 refugees from Afghanistan and Pakistan” read a recent news headline circulating in the media.  As a Pakistani, this headline carried more heartache than surprise. At a time when the Pakistani social media is abuzz with underlining the plight of the minority Rohingya-Muslim community of Myanmar, minorities and marginalized groups in our own backyard are fighting a battle of their survival. So how come Pakistan, a country established on grounds of secularism, reach this stage of deserting its own? Systematic constitutional marginalization, growing extremist narrative, and alleged state-backed persecution are some of the major reasons. Between January 2013 and June 2014, up to 3,753 Non-Muslim Pakistanis, especially Hindus, gave up their passports to acquire Indian Visas. Also, the Foreign Policy magazine ranked Pakistan as the third worst state in terms of group grievance, whereas Freedom House, in 2012, categorized the country as partially free for religious practice. Where Punjab has seen a spike a rise in extremism, resulting in more attacks on minority worship places, Sindh, on the other hand, has been known for forced conversions of the Hindu community. The Movement of Solidarity and Peace reports that forced conversion is one of the major reasons for minority group grievance in Pakistan. According to the Asian Human Rights watch, an average of 20-25 incidents of forced conversion and kidnappings take place in the Sindh province per month, mostly involving the Hindu community. Reports of Friday sermons in mosques announcing Jihad against the Hindu community in Sindh have also surfaced in the recent past, making Hindus an easy target for kidnapping and conversion. Additionally, local administration – including Police – is mostly providing impunity to influential culprits by refusing to lodge FIRs and complaints against the perpetrators, adding further to the woes of the victims. In Punjab, the situation is somewhat different....

TOP STORIES

TESTIMONIALS

I am also a member of National Assembly’s Standing Committee on Information and Broadcasting. Recently, we held a meeting with the Director General of Radio Pakistan and we told them to initiate such local programs (like Constituency Hour) in regional languages to educate and inform people. Even Indian Radio can be heard in FATA which is being used for propaganda purposes and must be closed. Therefore, we should launch some standard and quality programs like CRSS that will change the taste of the listeners.

Soniya Shams

Shaheed Benazir Bhutto Women University, Peshawar